Is Now the Right Time to Build a Custom Home in State College, PA?

siteROOST Editor • September 19, 2025

Is now a good time to build a home in State College, PA? For many people considering custom homes, the answer is maybe more than ever. The market conditions, costs, and limited inventory all factor into whether building makes sense—and for certain types of buyers, it’s looking pretty favorable. We will take a look at where things stand, what to watch out for, and when building your own home can beat buying.


Custom Amish build home in State College, PA. Fire place. Open concept. Large Windows

What's Going on in the State College Housing Market?

Here are a few key trends:

  • The current median listing home price in State College is around $449,500, up about 5.5% year-over-year. 
  • Homes are selling, but the inventory is fairly tight. New listings are lagging, and many homes go pending relatively quickly.
  • In some neighborhoods (for example State College South) prices have jumped significantly. 
  • The home‐value index continues to rise in the region. 

 

So high prices, rising steadily, and relatively low supply. All of those push buyers toward either paying premium for what’s available, or considering alternatives such as building your custom dream home.


Custom home builder home State College, PA. Farmhouse style kitchen
White cabinets and counter tops. Amish builder

What about current building costs in Central PA?

  • In Pennsylvania a custom home with higher end materials & finishes averages $300 to 450+ per square foot
  • "Basic" or builder grade new homes tend to run $200 to 320 per square foot
  • The cost of building a custom home in State College depends on numerous factors such as size of home, material used, etc. but averages $500,000-750,000+
  • Land costs can also be significant in the State College area. You will also need to account for site preparation, utility hook ups, permits and possibly more depending on location of the home

Build vs Buy: What does it come down to?

Given the current State College market + building costs, here are some factors that make building appealing.

 

Reasons building may be a strong choice now

1.    Customization & quality: If you want a custom home tailored exactly to your needs (layout, materials, finishes, energy efficiency, etc.), building gives you that flexibility. A local Amish custom builder can provide craftsmanship, durability, and finish choices that might be hard to find on the resale market.

2.    Value retention / appreciation: With home values rising (20+% year over year in some data sets) and inventory being tight, a newly built home may appreciate well, especially in a desirable location such as State College, PA. 

3.    Less competition when building land and new homes than bidding wars on existing homes. Resale homes in popular State College  neighborhoods are getting snapped up quickly and sometimes above list price. 

4.    Potential for energy savings / newer codes: New home builds can more easily incorporate modern standards for insulation, HVAC, windows, etc., potentially lowering operating costs over time.



Custom modern design home in State College, PA. Farmhouse style. 
Amish built home

What is the Benefit of Choosing a Custom Home Builder in the current market?

If you value craftsmanship and want something built to last, choosing a custom home builder is likely the right choice for you.


Choosing a custom home builder makes a lot of sense in State College's current housing market for the following reasons:

  • The resale market is expensive and competitive, making building a way to get more control and possibly more value per dollar spent.
  • With housing prices increasing, locking in costs now (before inflation or materials/labor costs escalate further) may be advantageous.
  • Working with a builder who uses traditional quality methods (good materials, solid construction) tends to reduce maintenance/ repair costs later, which over the long run may be economical.


How to Maximize Value when Building a Custom Home

  • Choose land carefully: location affects not just price, but utility and infrastructure costs, permitting, and proximity to amenities and schools.
  • Plan realistically: set your budget with cushion for cost overruns. Decide what features you truly need vs what would be nice. Custom builders often give excellent long-term value, but higher cost materials / custom finishes will increase price upfront
  • Understand timeline: expect months (often 9-12 or more) from land purchase to move-in. Delays can happen with weather, supply chain, inspections/permits.
  • Prioritize what saves you money long term: energy efficiency, low‐maintenance materials, good insulation and practical design.
  • Work with a reputable custom home builder


The expert team at Triple E Homes is here to help you build your forever home in State College and the surrounding area. Reach out today to schedule a consultation and discover how easy and rewarding the custom home process can be.


 Build local. Build custom. Contact us today to schedule a consultation.


Custom Amish built home in State College,
By siteROOST Editor August 8, 2025
Fall, Football, and Forever Homes: Why Penn State Football Season is the Perfect Time to Explore Life in State College with Triple E Homes
Custom amish built home State College, PA. Centre County custom home builer.
By siteROOST Editor July 7, 2025
If you’ve ever dreamed of designing your perfect home from the ground up, there’s no better place to do it than the heart of Central Pennsylvania. Whether you're envisioning a quiet retreat in the countryside or a family-focused estate near State College, working with an Amish custom home builder ensures a level of craftsmanship, tradition, and attention to detail that’s hard to match. In this post, we’ll walk you through the custom home building process —from initial planning to move-in day—while highlighting why so many families are turning to Amish home builders near State College, PA to bring their vision to life.
Custom Amish built home State College, PA
Best State, College PA neighborhoods
By siteROOST Editor May 30, 2025
Thinking of building a custom home in State College, PA? Explore the best neighborhoods for new construction, from scenic developments to family-friendly communities.
Custom Amish home builder State College, PA
By siteROOST Editor April 30, 2025
If you're dreaming of building a custom home with a backyard for entertaining and family activities, this guide will walk you through practical and beautiful ideas to bring that vision to life. And if you're in the State College, PA area, working with a local Amish custom home builder can ensure your space is crafted with the highest level of care, quality, and timeless style.

Triple e homes

A home should be as unique as the family who lives there. At Triple E Homes, we specialize in building custom homes that are unique and one-of-a-kind. 

LEARN MORE